John Mayer

Mid 2009 and Early 2010 (Dear John, The Story of Us, Superman, I Knew You Were Trouble)

Mayer tweeted about wanting to record a song with Swift in March 2009. The single Half of My Heart appeared on Mayer’s 2009 album Battle Studies. After the end of their twisted and secret relationship, Taylor wrote Dear John, which Mayer told Rolling Stone "really humiliated" him. In response, Taylor said it was presumptuous that he assumed the song had been meant for him. The Story of Us is about an encounter the two had at the 2010 CMA's. Superman was presumably written near the beginning of their relationship, and the lyric "I loved you from the very first day" is the hidden message for Dear John. Some would argue that Haunted is also about Mayer...but we may never know. The saga continues on Red with I Knew You Were Trouble - the tragic tale of Taylor's venture into "places she's never been" with the man she knew was trouble as soon as he walked in.Mayer has returned the favor penning at least two songs of his own about the relationship Paper Doll and Shadow Days.

Dear John (Speak Now)

Hidden Message: Loved You From The Very First Day

Dear John is Swift’s only track off Speak Now to directly address someone by name. Although many originally speculated that the song would refer to the traditional Dear John letter, she later confirmed that one of the songs on the album used, in typical Swift fashion, the guy’s real name. Her victim is singer-songwriter John Mayer who has known Swift for several years. The two have been linked many times over the last few years in addition to releasing a song together (Half Of My Heart). Swift has admitted that Dear John and The Story of Us share a suitor. The hidden message in the lyric booklet also hints to one of the album’s bonus tracks , reading, “loved you from the very first day.” This leads to the conclusion that Mr. Mayer inspired not one – not two – but at least three songs on Speak Now (though we have a feeling that Haunted is about him too).

Sources: 1, 2, 3

Superman (Speak Now)

Hidden Message: n/a

The bonus track Superman from Swift's third studio album Speak Now may be about Swift's relationship with John Mayer. The line, I loved you from the very first day, is also the hidden message from the song Dear John, and just to erase any lingering doubts later croons, he's not all bad like his reputation.